• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

State of Elections

William & Mary Law School | Election Law Society

Hide Search

Linda Greenhouse Speaks at William & Mary School of Law

Election Law Society · September 27, 2016 ·

By: Caiti Anderson & Kelsey Dolin

William & Mary Law School had the pleasure of hosting Linda Greenhouse on September 22. Ms. Greenhouse is a Pulitzer Prize winning columnist for the New York Times who has covered the Supreme Court for thirty years.

She is also a Senior Research Scholar in Law, Knight Distinguished Journalist in Residence, and Joseph Goldstein Lecturer in Law at Yale Law School, where she teaches various courses on the Supreme Court. Her books include Becoming Justice Blackmun, Before Roe v. Wade: Voices that Shaped the Abortion Debate Before the Supreme Court’s Ruling, The U.S. Supreme Court: A Very Short Introduction and The Burger Court and the Rise of the Judicial Right (written with Michael J. Graetz).

greenhouse_linda

Ms. Greenhouse spent the hour discussing her August 18 New York Times opinion article, “The Courts Begin to Call Out Lawmakers.” The article generated a lot of buzz as it delved into courts’ recent willingness to question the actions of legislatures in highly polarized areas, including the attempts of the Texas legislature to scale back access to abortion and recent voter ID cases in North Carolina and Texas. In the North Carolina case, the three-judge panel of the Fourth Circuit questioned why the state legislature sought to prevent fraud by implementing a system of voter ID – where the state failed to identify a single person who had ever been charged with committing in-person voting fraud within the state – rather than implementing a more stringent absentee voting regime, where there was, in fact, evidence of voter fraud. According to Ms. Greenhouse, “despite knowing that citizens who lacked the required identification were disproportionately [minorities], while those who voted by absentee ballot were disproportionately white, the legislators rejected amendments that would have extended identification requirements to absentee voting.” The Fourth Circuit pointed to a discriminatory purpose behind the law and struck it down.

In the discussion, Ms. Greenhouse noted the remarkable nature of this opinion. Courts are often hesitant to ascertain legislative purpose, even if the conditions surrounding the legislation are suspicious in large part because of the difficulties of assigning motive to multi-member bodies. The dramatic shift in 2016 represents something else entirely. As stated in her article, “Legislators, perhaps assuming they had friends in high judicial places, had taken bold, even flagrant steps to suppress the black vote and restrict women’s access to abortion. Judges responded, and even though their actions in some cases spoke more loudly than their words, these decisions mark a departure and make a difference.” Ms. Greenhouse ended her discussion by wondering whether this trend may continue in the future, especially when there is a ninth member on the Supreme Court.

North Carolina, Texas, Virginia election law, Election Law Society, Fourth Circuit, Greenhouse, Linda, Linda Greenhouse, NC voter ID, New York Times, NYT, Opinion Article, Pulitzer Prize, SCOTUS, Speaker, Supreme Court, The Courts Begin to Call Out Lawmakers, TX voter ID, Voter ID, William & Mary, William & Mary Law, William & Mary School of Law, William and Mary

Primary Sidebar

Pages

  • About Us
  • Election Law Glossary
  • Staff History
  • Links
  • Archived Pages
    • Citizens United + The States
    • Virginia Redistricting Competition

Search

View Posts by State

Archives

Tags

2016 Election 2020 Election Absentee ballots absentee voting Ballot Access ballot initiative Campaign Finance Citizens United Colorado Disenfranchise disenfranchisement Early Voting Election 2016 Electronic Voting Felon Voting Rights First Amendment Gerrymandering in-depth article judicial elections mail-in voting National Voter Registration Act North Carolina photo ID primary election Redistricting Referendum Registration Secretary of State state of elections Supreme Court Texas Virginia Vote by mail Voter Fraud Voter ID Voter Identification voter registration Voter Turnout voting voting and COVID Voting Machines Voting Rights Voting Rights Act VRA William & Mary

Blogroll

  • Election Law Issues
  • William & Mary Law School
  • Williamsburg Redistricting – "The Flat Hat" article

Friends

  • W&M Election Law Program

Contact Information:

To contact us, send an email to
wmstateofelections@gmail.com

Current Editorial Staff

Brendan W. Clark ’24, Editor-in-Chief
Rachel Clyburn ’24, Editor-in-Chief

State of Elections

Copyright © 2025 · Monochrome Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok